TShirtSlayer Heavy Metal Merch Gallery
  • Bands (0)
  • Groups (0)
  • Members (0)
  • (X)

World's largest community of heavy metal tshirt and battlejacket collectors.

TSS is supported by ‐ monitor web page changes with changedetection.io
Forums > All other metal related talk..

Do you consider Graveland to be "NSBM"? What do you think of "NSBM" as a label?

Tico Tyrant
Wed, 30/11/2011 - 02:08

*Before Responding* note- that I will have quite a bit to say about this as well. No one is forced to read what I write and can move on to a different post, but I don't want to see any complaints about how much I type, etc once you decide to stay at this post....If reading is too hard, just ignore it or respond to the question alone by itself, but do not read what I comment with and then complain about it's length, as by now most people know I do quite type a bit.I have a thinking mind and I like to reflect on music that demands reflection and I will hopefully come up with new and engaging topics of discussion at least once a month. If anyone does like the idea, send me a message letting me know of some other band topics or things you think I could discuss, otherwise... Thank you for the understanding! :D

The issue: So, lately I see many people in a black metal forum I'm in , every time I post a Graveland song,saying comments something like "fuck of racist black metal" or" fuck nsbm" or " this is shitty nasbm", etc....
However, despite the fact I only own a few Graveland cd's myself, I do listen to the band quite a lot on youtube when I can and for the majority of what Rob Darkens music is, I really can't consider these convictions to be well educated.

So, here are my thoughts:

1)What is Graveland?-
--------------------------------------------------------------
In my eyes-Graveland is Heathen Pagan Black metal, nothing more, nothing less..... I think some people need to get their convictions re assessed. Politics are quite simple, mundane and useless....if you look at Graveland's music, there is not a lot of lyrics regarding modern day political concepts let alone ones from the past or the 3rd reich. If people want to label bands as "nasbm" or "NSBM", “racist black metal” then they should listen to crap like: " Aryan Terrorism", "Waffen SS", "Der Sturmer", "Xenophobia" or "Wolfnacht", those are real NSBM bands in my point of view and if I had my way, it would be re labelled to “NSDAP” metal.

2)What is truly "NSBM"? Is the label as we know it, accurate?-
----------------------------------------------------------------
I don’t know everything about history,metal label standards, or politics, but what I do know is certain. Rob Darken the man, as a separate individual does have certain views that lead towards Right Hand Socialism and pride, but I feel that people should not confuse baseline National Socialism as a proto political standard, with hardline NSDAP ideals, that were formed by radicals in the mid 1920s. True “NSBM”, or as I would like to call it, “NSDAP” music, is stupid, because as black metal, it attempts or often embraces “Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei" ideals and concepts, thus reflecting heavy racial supremacy,political fascism, or at the very least, anti Semitism. So, in a sense, this common label of “NSBM” it is also a bastardization of early movement of National Socialism itself, which began long before Hitler, or the 20’s NSDAP movements, were ever around.For example, with regards to lyrical content: I think people can often stop at symbolism of black sun dials and immediately associate such symbols with Nazis, but if one does the research behind the pagan aspect of these symbols, they will soon find that there are other, older meanings with regards to their purpose in the songs.

3)What is Graveland about, what does Rob Darken's music comprise of?-
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Rob Darken's music(*so far, to my listening knowledge*) does not discuss these other ideas regarding third reich propaganda. Most actual “National Socialists” that I have spoken with, or at least learned about in History, don't give a shit about the third reich or jew hating or any of that foolishness, it has more to do with ancestral pride and certain political leanings. Of course Graveland is considered by many to be very strict "NSBM" but when I turn on a Graveland song, all I hear are lyrics of: war, pride, mysticism, pagan ancestry and might. In his first few demos, there are a few songs that point towards anti Semitism, but were never strongly followed up on.
Since his first set of demos and ep's, his music has taken a huge evolution. Rob Darken is inspired by the roots and cult of warrior bloodlines, Celtic Lore and ancestral spiritual pride, hence why many of the songs are about battles, lore and warriors. He does talk and discuss the failed system of multiculturalism in some of his music, perhaps in a hidden way, so I will elaborate as to why that might be a valid issue in his music. I think through reading his interviews and by understanding the social structure of his home country and the world itself, one can conclude, that through a certain veil of judgement, the multicultural system might seem all fine and dandy, but evidence of why this system within the paradigm of the globe fails, surfaces every day. The “multicultural system” is a vain and flawed concept, which does need improving. It's about staying true to ethnic roots and cultural ties, but also knowing how to properly integrate into another society if anything at all. In this line of thought, the music that Darken creates in Graveland, has little or nothing to do with racial superiority at the detriment to others, etc....

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4)My final thoughts:
In my final conclusive thoughts with regards to bands such as “Graveland”, I can only say this: In the greater expanse of genre labeling and metal itself, as an evolving art/music form, it is always the fans or the other musicians, media, etc that will first be the ones to label bands, but half the time they don't do the research before making statements or accusations. In this case, Darken, time and time again has to explain to people, that his music is not technically "NS" black metal and it is definitely not, as I have shown, “nsdap” metal. Of course songs about iron, blood and valor can transcend to some ideas regarding national socialism as a proto political concept, but Rob Darken's personal views aside, his music is undeniably great. He is truly dedicated to his black/pagan metal craft, it is focused, full of power, purpose and interesting to listen to and if people can't see that in his work, then I feel that they shouldn't be concerning themselves over it in the first place or attempting to label it blindly. I feel as a label, "NSBM" is incredibly backwards and that perhaps bands that do adhere to that concept as it's commonly known as today, should be re labelled as "NSDAP metal, for both their essence, the purpose of the rest of the metal world and it's musical/historical focus.

So, what are your thoughts. Am I wrong? Are there parts where I'm right? What do you think of Graveland? Is Graveland “NSBM”? ...and finally- Should true “nsbm” be considered within current musical standards, to be re labelled as “NSDAP” metal? or are the two separate forms of music?


almostwilt's picture

random guess, sure

Maddolis's picture

I'd say they are.
Also NSBM isn't a genre, it's a categorization.

Tico Tyrant's picture

I would agree that it is a categorization, but I would also say, that under false interpretation, it has in a way become a "genre" or a sound all by itself, because it is immediately identifiable by certain bands approaches to metal.
Anyways, perhaps it is more of a categorization, but it definitely has a lot of influence within the sound of black metal and pagan metal.
Thanks for checking out my post!

Maddolis's picture

I'd say a lot of the bands inspire each other and thus a few of them have a similar sound, but I wouldn't find it to have distanced itself from blackened folk far enough to become its own sound, seeing as there are non-NS/extremist right-wing bands with similar sounds.
Sounds like something you could explore for postgrad studies.

Tico Tyrant's picture

Yes, there must always be a step back from the music to some degree, I'm glad you responded to what I wrote!

Hmnn I see what you are saying, I suppose though as a concept, or as a "system" it is flawed, not wrong in any way, though some seem to think it is, but it is flawed.I would agree that it does stem from the roots of a historical origin within many countries and has thus become a pattern of reality for earth. However, I think there are aspects of multiculturalism that can be refuted. For example to quote you

", most of the countries in the Americas have more or less "multicultural" societies, and they are a result of the discovery of already populated lands by other ethnic groups, that started immigration, and when they managed to make a society, this new product experienced again immigration by yet another ethnical groups. Therefore, multiculturalism is not some kind of system you can choose, like when you choose between communism or capitalism, or between brands of cheese in the supermarket. It is a thing that comes with the origin of a nation"

all of this is true,especially with regards to countries in the Americas, but I believe to a certain extent, there is a way to take a choice. One can not choose to avoid multiculturalism,as it does undeniably relate to immigration, which will never go away, nor should it..... but one can choose to avoid certain aspects that go along with multiculturalism. Certain factors,that by no means have been there since the origin of the nation holding dear the idea of "multiculturalism", take in hand the fact that this idea stems from the origin of a countries social standards, one must then question how integration affects this concept.

Multiculturalism opens up the boundaries for more social acceptance to: way of life, racial integration,tolerance, music, arts, etc; but, in turn,standards become skewed and it ends up bending this to a point where a society can actually become completely lost from what it's root existence really was, its own cultural arts, music, way of life, history, etc....an example, would be the country where I currently reside, Canada, which prides itself on being multicultural and inclusive, the downside is that Canada, can no longer logically be considered a "unique" nation as there seems to be no real identity to it's existence,nor are there any more easily identifiable "Canadian" principles, which leads into an issue of socio multiracial co existence.This of course, is probably going to be the continuing reality for places like North America and so it probably should be, but for other countries or places in the world, that have perhaps kept relatively isolated from outer ethnic or cultural influence, it is something that might have to be worked upon....something that will have to be improved, if it is ever expected to be accepted.

I think that there are certain places in the world that multiculturalism is actually becoming a standard for people to move into another society, but not integrate into it and therefore engaging in violent or territorial behavior over what was never theirs in the first place, a common example would be what parts of rural France are going through, with regards to tensions between ethnic Francophones and immigrant Muslims engaging in violence, violence that has come about because of a government mandated multicultural existence....

Tico Tyrant's picture

.....People will often move into another country,such is the nature of living in 2011 with the global populace booming every day(I think it's 7 or 8 billion now?), but hold dear to their own ethnic and racial pride, way of life,etc..this is only natural and it is good to hold these things dear, it's what makes people unique..roots are incredibly important, but it is not good if it happens to the detriment of the people who have already lived in that particular country, far longer.I guess what I mean, is that if one is supposed to be integrating into another society,in a "multicultural way" then why does it now become ok to ignore that societies core principles? I guess this is the kind of thing I am getting at.Then again, I am very young and really don't understand all these issues to the fullest, I am suggesting though and I will stand behind the idea, that multiculturalism is ok with me, but I can understand why people like Rob Darken or others, see it as flawed... I can definitely say that it needs improving, because it's certainly not going away! haha

Blüdrayne's picture

well... no. immigration itself is not natural. neither is it enjoyable for most migrants. the large majority of immigration is due to capitalism, where employers actively and consciously seek to employ foreigners who would work for less. In turn this leads to high unemployment among the native populace. such immigrants do not try to integrate as they don't see their new country as a new home, even if they are permanent residents.

*EDIT

before anyone starts bringing up the white pride comments, please note i'm not even white in the first place.

Tico Tyrant's picture

ahhh I follow you now, I would definitely agree about control.

Blüdrayne's picture

actually there has been that problem recently in my country, and i agree. but i must stress the difference between multiracialism and multiculturalism.

Plague's picture

To me, it doesn't really matter what their beliefs are, or their message for that matter...it's more about the music and the lyrics themselves. Someone (on here I think) commented about how no one really turns a head when we listen to songs that glorify Satan or kill Christians, but when it comes to other nationalities/religions (such as Jewish/Hebrew/racist) people get very concerned and angry about that music. (NO, I'm not antisemitic) but just noting how we accept some things but not others. Another example is that Eminem is widely accepted and even played on the radio, so it's okay for him to sing about killing people and violent things, but not so much for black metal bands to do the same. Bottom line, I guess it's best to just hate everyone equally! (and...not to get too concerned about the political/religious beliefs of a band).

Tico Tyrant's picture

Thanks for reading the forum question Plague!

It's true there must be some kind of separation when listening to music,especially considering that not all music can realistically be taken intrinsically, especially if it's the artists personal vision.However, I think obviously with certain bands like Graveland, there must be some connection between the music's purpose and the sound, but it is how this connections is perceived by many metal fans, that I have an issue with.

Your comparison between these socio-musical subjects and their contrast against "acceptable" radio material, is a good example of part of what I am getting at.

I also know exactly what you mean about hating all people equally(to a certain degree)....but that's a whole other bag of chips!!

Deathcore.Is.Not.Metal.'s picture

tl;dr to everything you write. Lol

Tico Tyrant's picture

I don't really respect people who write tl:dr .I do respect people who, if they don't like large amounts of writing,or aren't interested in my posts,leave the post alone or move on. I did make a special message at the top of the post, before my writing, for all the people that complain about my large masses of words,to give them a heads up about the length and the options regarding comments, so you have no excuse to ignore that...it's not like it wasn't visible.

I also gave options to people, specifically for this forum post/question. If you find my writing annoying, or hilarious, or whatever, simply don't respond,or if you choose to respond...make the response worth my while, considering I went into effort to share my thoughts. Typing "tl;dr" on any post is no different from people who constantly troll people. So if you don't constantly troll people, then you also should have no reason to make pointless comments like "tl;dr". I think you will understand what I mean, hopefully! and thanks.

Deathcore.Is.Not.Metal.'s picture

My comment was more along the lines of a joke. I just don't find the need to read (or write for that matter) several paragraphs, in an idea that can easily be summed up in just a few sentences. Wherein that was why I put tl;dr, the title sums up, perfectly, all that needs to be said. It's nice to elaborate sometimes, just to get your point across. Though, friend, there is a fine line between elaborating and rambling. I believe it was there, but I'm not going to pick through to look for a disclaimer of recapitulation for the written piece.

Perhaps you've seen some posts of mine stating my detest for trolls and the likes. Making the use of implying "tl;dr" is correlated to trolling. Impressive maneuver nevertheless haha. However, as my initial response was that it was used as a bit of a joke, rather than a serious reply. When a seriously reply is not given, one should not take the reply seriously. Nor should they write a serious reply back. Deal reason with reason; no? I did intend to reply with a well thought out, yet certainly diminutive response. I still plan on which actually. It's late now though, and far be it beyond the belief of many, I like my sleep.

Did I write this long on purpose?

Yeah.

Though I did with ironic, and friendly intentions.

Tico Tyrant's picture

Of course now I can see this true reality of your response, thus making my comment somewhat foolish in essence. I agree that there is no need to write many paragraphs, if a *simple* idea can be summed up in a few sentences or words...but I think that kind of idea can't really apply to the subject matter of my post, or...well..many of my posts!(I could be very wrong)

The reason why I responded like I did so quickly, and the problem, lies with this: I see "tl;dr" or "you're writing is too long" etc,these phrases, after so many times and it becomes hard to see who is trolling, who just flat out hates my writing, who is too lazy and who is joking, hence why that response I made, would apply to anyone at this point making a statement that was similar to yours. I too know that I ramble on, but I do ramble on with focus, it's not like a random collection of schizophrenic anomalies...I'm working on keeping things clear and concise, short even(if possible haah) and organizing thoughts, even adding #'s, but it's not something that will change over night.

Still I understand that your comment was meant to be held with friendly intentions and as a bit of a joke, but my patience with such things is pretty thin, almost as bad as when people constantly use the word "bro"....for some reason and I can't quite say why, tl;dr really get's under my skin, then again...I suppose I'm weak for letting it! haha

Tico Tyrant's picture

Imagine if this writing was made, as I was... before taking ritalin!!!! then t-slayer would really be in for a show eheheh.

ShieldbitersValhalla's picture

+1 to your entire post. There are so many different varieties of people doing black metal. There are some bands who have members who were NS first and foremost, and who then happen to make black metal *AFTER* on the side. Some people are serious, and not kids who get into black metal first, then throw a little bit of NS in there like some seasoning. People who are sincere NS, then happen to discover BM, would better fit the notion NSDAP metal, or NSDAP. Or in other words, when NSDAP is there first, then BM shows up, and not vise versa, NSDAPBM could be a good classification I suppose.

Now, I'm holding the Resistance Records 2000 "Raiders of Revenge" split with Honor and Graveland in my hands, looking inside the case, and I see behind the disc as a "tray photo": "Aryan Brotherhood of Fight", super-imposed over a group shot of Robert Fudali pointing his sword at me, with the members of Honor on either side of him, with their right arms flat, straight out in the air. This is the closest to NS I have seen of anything from Graveland. Rob may agree and even support bands like Honor, but to call Graveland, as a band, NSBM... well that's not terribly accurate. I mean it's a split with *HONOR*. On top of that, it's released by RESISTANCE RECORDS! That must be where all the NS comes from in the design of this split. Comparing this release with other Graveland artwork, the connection can be seen between any possible NS content on the split, as far as art is concerned, and Honor/Resistance Records; regardless of the personal values of Robert.

Tico Tyrant's picture

Well, thanks very much for reading my madness !(it's fueled by one cold beer "EIN BIER IST KRIEG" haha) I know what you mean about band members shifting personal approach, for example even Polish bands such as Thunderbolt, have members that at a younger age and even in early albums, that chose to rely heavily on NS views that mainly drew from nsdap ideals,so in a very weird way... the music was never "nsbm" but rather something else,attempting to offer a political basis to "black metal" but since then their music has changed. Even so, there has to be some level of separation between the music and the individuals and such is the case with Rob Darken.....bridging a direct gap between the two has always seemed weird for me and I know that the same things happen to bands like Satanic Warmaster and even at times Drowning the Light, or Horna.

I have recently found out that Darken has other musical affiliations and has personally done work with bands that follow a more strict approach such as you've mentioned, but as you've pointed out, for the majority of the time...his music in Graveland, *as it's own entity*, doesn't seem to follow this affiliation.

For some reason I thought Resistance Records released a different split featuring Graveland, but now I'm back tracking and can see that indeed Honor was with Graveland....it's helpful that someone else has a physical copy of the work, though I must say the whole arms straight out is certainly blatant....I always knew many musicians, especially in pagan and black metal scenes , did support certain controversial views, but I never expected the evidence of it, to be visually blatant !I guess the "NSBM" label for his music is maybe at the most, predictable, but certainly not accurate.

Anyways, I ask these questions and offer my views just so I know how others will think and because I'm interested in engaging topics. I've already had a few problems when I came up with the idea to share Graveland in these black metal forums that I am on, so when I can get a sense of how others agree, or disagree, interpret, etc..it allows me to deal with these issues in a more global manner. I do know that when I eventually get a Graveland patch, it's going to anger some people at shows, or perhaps be labelled as something....so I guess I better be ready for it!

Blüdrayne's picture

@ topic, graveland is no more NSBM than satanic warmaster or nokturnal mortum, or even newer absurd. they have members who are supportive of national socialism but that does not make their music NSBM. Even if it did, i still feel that they are entitled to an equal opportunity to present their views in the "marketplace of ideas".

mayhempunk666's picture

+1

mayhempunk666's picture

ehhh, i say that Graveland is simply pagan black metal. But i think a strong analytic case could be made based on songs such as
1. Battle of Wotan's Wolves
2. White Beasts of Wotan
3. White Hand's Power
4. Following the Voice of Blood

but like Bludrayne said, Graveland is just like Satanic Warmaster, Nokturnal Mortum, and newer Absurd.

Even if Graveland was overt, goose stepping, hitler worshipping NSBM i would probably still listen to him. He makes good music and imo really nails the atmosphere of pre christian europe and so i have no complaints. He also isnt a total "look at me, im so kvlt, look at me im a Nazi" attention whore who constantly changes his position on everything like another BM musician whom i do not need to name, which for me is a plus.

Food for thought, if we are going to base a bands characterization on the personal beliefs of band members, then Slayer is a christian band seeing as Tom Araya is catholic.

its a little late, and im a little tired so these are my only thoughts for now, but tomorrow i will probably pop back in with some more input

and i couldn't agree more with you Tico

Blüdrayne's picture

oh and btw, so satanic warmaster or nokturnal mortum have any explicitly nazi or racist lyrics? or are they something like burzum?

mayhempunk666's picture

Satanic Warmaster has songs like "My Dreams of 8" and others that briefly reference Aryan race but alot of his lyrics can be taken as metaphor

He has also said that the Third Reich was a major influence to him, but he never really has commented on being a nazi or a racist. That i know of

Tico Tyrant's picture

Good point, things even....controversial ideas, can be interpreted by musicians in different ways.

ShieldbitersValhalla's picture

Nokturnal Mortum has/had a member who is/was NS for certain, and had part in bands such as Aryan Terrorism, and Finist.

beholderinsorrow's picture

I can understand NSBM bands to some extent, such as ancestral pride, but I think those who support NSADP or Nazi beliefs are mistaken about the spirit of black metal. They should read about "Entartete Kunst" (Degenerate Art). I believe something like black metal certainly would have been classified under this term.

Tico Tyrant's picture

Very good way of wording it, I definitely agree.

676,030 items in the gallery, 911,166 comments, and 545 items have changed hands in the last month.

Guess this TShirt!

Can you guess which metal tshirt this is from?

Can you guess which metal TShirt this is from? Click here for all previous tshirt guesses

Recent Comments

  • 2 minutes ago
    Ah, okay then my bad. Still cool you are right.
  • 13 minutes ago
    I am interested in this shirt. Can I buy it? How can I contact you? My Facebook name is Iddaris Kharee.
  • about an hour ago
    Impeccable
  • about 3 hours ago
    official licensed ?
  • about 3 hours ago
    thanks
  • about 4 hours ago
    I talked to him and he said that it’s not his design nor did he make them, still cool though.
  • about 4 hours ago
    Awesome layout!
  • about 4 hours ago
    Would you sell?
  • about 5 hours ago
    Sick! Do you know the year on this one
  • about 6 hours ago
    thx
  • about 7 hours ago
    Their music truly holds the key to unlocking that gut wrenching nostalgic feeling in my stomach. I LOVE Men At Work!!!!
  • about 8 hours ago
    It was, so many killer bands played!
  • about 8 hours ago
    valuterò l'offerta solo se nel bagagliaio c'è il prof di bella
  • about 8 hours ago
    Nice photos man, looks like a killer line up of old and new!
  • about 8 hours ago
    Hell ya
  • about 8 hours ago
    One of the coolest OG patches!